Writing About It
After some thought I decided to delete the story I’d posted here yesterday or the day before. For one thing, it’s probably too long to have as a blog post (which puts some oomph behind my little ad for FLOAT last week). For another, I’m embarrassed by it. I’m sorry.
I’m just not having a good week, but I don’t really want to make this a blog of angsty writing and fishing for compliments, encouragement, or praise. It’s all great and very kind and warm, but people, including me, get tired of that after a while, of constantly reading complaining and bad day shit, and I should probably just take my own advice I gave to Friar on being grumpy, on Brett’s post yesterday. At the same time, perhaps I should take Tei’s advice. Dude, she said, after I commented on her post yesterday, you must be fucked up. Write about it.
The truth is, I can’t write about and exorcise any demons I might have that are causing me to have the longest writer’s block in the history of humankind. I don’t know what they are. I’ve spent a lot of time running from shit that looks like hard work, so those demons are pretty suppressed, I’m telling you. I’m not feeling sorry for myself. To pinpoint it, I’m feeling rather discouraged. My sister, whose view I respect a great deal, said the “Catharsis” story’s beginning seemed a bit forced and she didn’t really like it until the character started with the bread. Then Colin (whose view I also respect a great deal) wrote that he was confused by the ending and wondered what I meant. I answered I don’t know. I think it was something about starting over, being free. Shit, I have no clue. I thought the end a bit weird myself. As though it’s trying to say something really important, but no one really knows what. So finally, because I’m not going to rework it after ten years, the story goes. If you insist on reading it because you got half started or something yesterday, I can always email it to you. The story didn’t get more than a comment, so also now I’m embarrassed. I don’t know why I posted something so old or so long, for that matter. No one has the time to read that much, I think, either. Then I wonder, is it like if you can’t say anything nice, don’t say anything at all? (PS. I’m not fishing for compliments here, I don’t want you to answer and fawn over the story because you think if I don’t I’ll go have another southern comfort or three.)
Yesterday sucked (I felt as I do now and I had my head on my desk a lot, practically drooling with boredom over the proofread I am doing, and I was trying not to fall asleep and then I had a southern comfort and grapefruit mixed drink and it tasted good but made me feel like I wanted to die. I had to lie down and it wasn’t even a shot of alcohol. I thought I was going to hurl). Today I got up and showered and went to write and read what I’ve written over the last couple of days and got depressed about it and didn’t even know if it was worth continuing. To be fair, Colin also said that it seemed unreasonable to expect the perfect story after taking ten years off. Sounds practical, logical, whatever, but if you know me, perfect writing is all there is. You do it or you don’t.
A friend and colleague, a published author, called me this morning to encourage me in my writing and in the idea that I should pursue editing fiction rather than continue with this mind-numbing non-fiction no one is likely to read. I’m happy he believes I can do it, and I know he truly does because he would actually tell me otherwise. But I do feel like a huge fraud when it comes to writing. Or like that kid who loves to sing and wants to share but really can’t sing and no one has the heart to say anything.
My sister also wrote to set me straight. “I wish you were listening to Stuart McLean [if you don't know who this is, look him up. He rocks and we're huge fans] last night! He said he gets a lot of questions from people who want to be writers, and they always ask him the same question (and frankly, he’s sick of it): How and where do you get your ideas??? And he says, ideas?! Ideas are easy! Ideas are a dime a dozen! The hardest part about writing is the writing. Choosing the idea that will stick and making it stick. Sitting down and doing it, going over it and over it and rewriting it with his producer a million times just so that it’s nevermind perfect but at least okay to make public. His advice: write for something or someone and give yourself a deadline. It’s the only way.
“And I know [I hear you say], but I have to work! And in that case, switch your priorities. Let the food go mouldy in the fridge, eat take-out for a month, never wash the dishes, don’t do laundry, and you can forget about combing your hair. Make friends with the dust bunnies, accept that a plant or two might die, leave the cottage shut up (actually, in your case, at least writing is mobile), exercise is a no-no, and chocolate-covered coffee beans a must. Your husband might miss you, but he’ll also be very proud of you, that, although you’re a disgusting slob (and if your husband is a disgusting slob like mine, then you don’t even have to worry about it), you’re actually doing what you both know you should be doing, and not being miserable about not doing it. The flip side to being totally miserable when you’re not doing it is being a bad-tempered, angry potty-mouth when you are doing it. And don’t forget the constant berating yourself (out loud) for being a terrible, no-good writer. And then you ask yourself, why am I doing this then???? To totally paraphrase my other boyfriend Tom Allen from the CBC: Animals do things to get rewards. Dogs do silly things to get food and affection, people do silly things to get money. Why on earth do people practise their whole lives and beat themselves up over being an artist? What’s the reward? The 2 minutes of hormonal rush to the brain when you’re on stage before a show, the 2 minutes when you get those final brushstrokes and you’ve nailed it, the 2 minutes of hormonal rush to the brain when you finish a story? It’s a small pellet of food, but it must be a pretty big damn reward.”
That’s my sis, everybody. Tough act to follow.
Filed under: Uncategorized | 28 Comments


Steph
Ahhh…who sez your story was too long for a Blog post? I liked it.
That’s the problem here…the blogosphere is starting to train people to expect wisdom and meaningful thoughts to be perfectly summarized in 200-word sound-bytes.
You wrote something from the heart, and you put it out there (unedited) for everyone to read. It was a lot of work, and it took a lot of guts.
Actually, I’d like to see more people post this kind of original, creative writing.
So many people are telling us how to DO it…but you are one of the few who actually DID.
Awww, Friar!! I’m simultaneously blushing and fighting back tears!
Thanks, man. Your last sentence especially is really encouraging. I’m one of those who likes to be different from the rest.
I actually just assumed it was too long. Most people read many blogs and also during work time, so I thought maybe it was too long for them to be interested in. The other problem is that most people also have almost negligible attention spans these days! That’s why writing has changed so much.
Thanks for the compliments on my story. I didn’t realize it at first, but they make me want to not give up on the one I’ve started recently. I hope the feeling lasts!
A lot of it, dear one, is just writing about what you don’t know. I think it might be this, or maybe this over here. There’ll be mounds of I don’t know before you hit one tiny truth. Then you write about that truth a lot, and other stuff will come to light, and then there won’t be any more of that vein of truth, so you’ll have to start with more I don’t know, and you’ll hit another nugget. It’s like mining for gold. Takes forever. At the end of it all, though, you have this shining mound of truths about yourself, and that is more than most people will ever have.
Write, girl. Don’t wait until you have something specific to write. Just write. Truth only appears to those who seek it, and writing is the best way I’ve ever found to do it.
Also, I was just being cute at you, hon, not critical. I have no idea if you’re fucked up. I assume you are on the same level we all are. Only one guy in this world was ever perfect. And we killed him.
And people LOVE the long blog posts. Don’t be absurd. Otherwise I’d be out of a job.
Steph
You CAN and WILL. Seek your Inner Garden of Possibilities. Reach for the stars. Find your own destiny. Don’t worry, be happy.
Fuzzy little Leprechauns, and elves dancing on crab-grass.
Think Pink Hearts, Yellow Diamonds, Orange Stars, Green Clovers, and now NEW BLUE DIAMONDS.
(Insert Smurf song here): La-la-lah-lah-lah LAAAAAH.
And remember Joey Joe-Joe Shabadoo.
He lost his toes in a tragic Quilting Accident, but he went on to win the OrniceVille tiddly-wink championship.
He did it because he COULD..and he FOLLOWED his DREAMS.
So go for it….keep up your writing!
(Oh MAN..I’m LOSIN’ it here!)
@ Tei: Thank you, thank you. And I know you weren’t being critical. I thought it was funny! But there was so much truth to what you said at the same time. Crap, did I make you sound mean, not putting the comment in context? I didn’t mean to!
You are the first person I’ve ever heard say “write about what you don’t know.” But I know what you mean. And I think you’re probably right about just writing. I need to change my rule about being perfect at everything I start. I don’t know how yet. And I need to stop obsessing over being struck by inspiration and writing only then. I just find it so unpleasant to write when I have no ideas. And ironic that I have no ideas in a vast sea of human experience and observation.
As for long blog posts, I actually thought of you. And I enjoy, along with others, reading something of substance that’s also entertaining. I just freaked out about my content.
@ Friar: AHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! You devil.
You could always reserve a section of your blog specifically devoted to your fiction.
I don’t know why we do this. I think we have to get it out. I think we are hard wired for stories and some of us are the tellers.
Yeah, and you don’t always know what you are writing. You are just mixing a lot from your life, other’s lives, etc. to make some energy move through space and time.
I think it’s pretty normal to freak out on content. I remember my first story workshop in college. Okay, so I’m an older student and went back. Anyway, here I am in my thirties and I have these twenty somethings critiquing my story. I was scared shitless and couldn’t even look at them. This one guy ripped it to shreds because, well because he was very Christian and this story wasn’t and it hit a chord with him. I felt like I was going to die. I think I possibly did, but then I was reborn into something else, some other person who could take a critique with a grain of salt.
My advice for critiques/story workshopping is this: If it resonantes with you and helps the story, keep it. If it doesn’t, fuck it. You don’t have to take everyone’s advice.
And what about science fiction? Who really knows that?
@ Ellen: Oh, I just suggested that in answer to your other comment! About having a separate page for short stories. I’m not sure how.
GASP!! That Christian dude needs to learn how to critique a story!! There’s so much I could say on that…
The story “Catharsis” was actually born out of what I was feeling at the time so naturally it resonated with me. Everything I write does. Inconsistencies and all that kind of thing I can fix. My concern is whether or not the what I write (even outside this story) is actually GOOD. You know? It doesn’t have to appeal to everyone, though people do have to relate to it in some way for it to be successful, in my opinion, but it does have to be worthy of praise.
Sci-fi: good point. There’s a lot of imagination mixed in there, but you still have to be able to understand and relate to some sort of human experience in them, I think.
@Friar,
Timmy did it too. But because he lost all his arms and legs when he fell down the well, someone else had to tell his story for him
@Steph,
I read your story. I just didn’t make the time to come back and tell you. I like it. Don’t quit.
I actually was at the library and got about half of the way through your story and had to do other things…I came back here today, specifically to read the rest of it!! (please email it to me…)
And remember, WE make the rules on the internet…Don’t feel forced in to doing things a certain way because a lot of people seem to…Do what feels right!! Hugs
@Brett: Ahahahaha! I heard about Timmy. (And I wish I could stop thinking of South Park!)
And thank you. I’m happy you liked it. I’ll just keep plugging away till you guys tell me to please stop.
LARA!!! Hi friend!! I didn’t know you were here!!
I will not email you the story. I will post it here again tonight.
I’m so sorry I’ve been such a suck, everyone. And a quitter. I didn’t see comments so I just assumed it must have bit the big one. I feel embarrassed.
PS. I’m not purposely holding off or anything. I just need to finish this edit and then I will have a look around the site for the best way to post the story(ies).
PS – thanks for the pingback
And no, don’t stop. Unless you want to, that is.
No, I really, really don’t want to.
Good.
We blogospherians do enjoy short, compact posts. That’s also why longer posts stand out. I love running across long posts–they are juicier and more filling.
Quitting isn’t always quitting. Sometimes it’s just taking a break.
I didn’t have a chance to read the story in question. I hope you do repost it.
Hey Shawn:
Thanks for that! It’s good news because I’m all about the juicy and more fulfilling. WAIT – that didn’t sound good.
Oh well.
PS. Yes I’ll repost. I have to figure out how to make a section where I can put only fiction. It seems a page is just one post? I’ll have to figure it out…
@Brett
Timmy became a mouth painter and now his critically-acclaimed work is shown in the Guggenheim Musuem in New York.
(The little bastard…!)
@Friar: AHAHAHAHAHA!
[gasp!] I can’t stop laughing!!
@Friar,
And we *should* be just like Timmy. Let’s get drunk and fall down a well…
All it takes is one Southern Comfort for me! I’ll see ya down there…
@Brett
I’ll bring the booze….you find the well.
Shouldn’t be too hard to find in Splat Creek. (Half the place dosen’t even get municipal water).
Wait, if it’s easy to find where you are, YOU find the well! We’ll ALL bring the booze.
UPDATE: other pages are static so I can only edit them, not actually post to them. That blows. My idea, then, is to create a fiction or short stories page and just add the new piece on top when I edit. That SUCKS, but I’m not sure what else I can do.
WHAT???I have a busy day and you hit the delete button?
Please bring that post back or e-mail it to me..I beg you.
Hey Tei…I always say that about the ONE PERFECT GUY.
Man…I don’t want HIS job.
Steph. You want to know the word count on my post today?
The one you said you liked? I got to tell you it makes me nervous. And then there was So much I left out, and that’s what we end up chatting about in the comments My posts are between 600 and 1200. today was longer. ..sheesh. Sometimes I’m a blabbermouth.
My last job in the cubicle was as a proofreader and editer. That’s hard on a writer.Not impossible-mind you- but hard. Because it trains you to put an EAGLE EYE CRITICAL EYE on the writer and rip that stuff apart. ( It never taught me to spell though) I often said that that job ruined the creativity in me.
Here is the good news-It didn’t. It made me better. But it took me awhile to learn how to channel which hat I was wearing and when to put one on and when to take one off.
Steph,
When you are writing, let that editer go. You can’t be an editer and a writer at the same time. That critic chatting inside your head needs to shut up while you are working. It can happen, it takes some practice. Have you read all of Julia Cameran’s books? I would love to chat more with you about this but this comment is turning into a blog.
Wendi: It’s back, it’s back, don’t hit me!!
(See newest post.)
You said some very wonderful things, and I especially loved you telling me to let the editor go. I too have often said that it’s killed my creativity, not least because it’s simply a left-brained activity. But you’re right, it’s damn near impossible to write anything when I can’t stop trying to get it perfect before I move on to the next sentence or paragraph. Talk about unproductive.
I haven’t read Julia’s book yet, or her other ones. But comment as much as you like: I’ll read it all, and listen.
Even though you have apparently re-published the short story you deleted – it lives on through my google reader. Just so you know – anyone reading blogs through a reader will most likely see any post you delete, because it only deletes off your blog and not in the reader….
and re: tei’s comment about the one perfect guy? huh? I’m assuming she’s talking about Jesus, and I like to stay away from all theology in a public forum BUT Jesus wasn’t perfect. That was kind of the point, wasn’t it? He being all human and imperfect and such?
Of course, maybe she’s talking about another perfect guy that “we” killed….. but that Jesus dude was NOT perfect. Nobody is. Even the ones that have giant mythologies surrounding them.